Message Boards

You are here: Message Boards > Topics > Genealogy Software > General > Entering data vs. importing GEDCOM to new software
Names or keywords
All Boards   General - Family History & Genealogy Message Board

Entering data vs. importing GEDCOM to new software

  Replies: 5

Re: Entering data vs. importing GEDCOM to new software

kj_norway  (View posts) Posted: 18 Mar 2012 4:03PM GMT
Classification: Query
Curt points out a problem that most people and software products don't know how to resolve. What data goes where!

It is NOT wrong to place cemetery names, church names and street addresses at the beginning of the "PLACE" field, except when the program you are using says that it is wrong.

But it is right when the product you are using says it is right!! Every program has it's own way to do things that are niether right or wrong just inconsistant. And for most people that inconsistancy will never be seen unless they evaluate, change or use other people's software or receive a GEDCOM for another program.

Curt will find that if he moves to another program having the cemetery names, church names and street addresses in the "Description" field will probably cause him to move the data again, because this field does not always exist in every program and it is very likely not put in the GEDCOM correctly by FTM.

** I Never Except a GEDCOM from Outside my Program **

For two reasons:

1) My program is very GEDCOM compliant and most other programs are not, therefore data will not be in the right place.
2) My standards for data entry and accuracy are very strict while most other people's are not. I like to review each piece of data and therefore if I'm reviewing it, why not enter it as I review?

I once used Generations and the GEDCOM it created was very poor and most data was not imported correctly by my next program PAF. Much of this data from PAF was then not imported correctly by the next program I used.
SubjectAuthorDate Posted
jharveland 6 Feb 2012 7:56PM GMT 
Ted Pack 20 Feb 2012 1:02PM GMT 
curmil 21 Feb 2012 11:54PM GMT 
jharveland 22 Feb 2012 7:18PM GMT 
curmil 22 Feb 2012 7:40PM GMT 
kj_norway 18 Mar 2012 4:03PM GMT 
   

Find a board about a specific topic

Surnames or topics

Page Tools