Hi!
Yes, my post is old and when I changed my email address I forgot to update. Tonight was just going back to looking over some info and found this post of yours. I don't know if you did go into NY and check out things there. We did a few years back. Still have a cousin from the Tompkins side I correspond with from time to time. So much history involves these families in NY . I have more info on the Garretts and would find it and give it to you if you are interested. I saw a site tonight that had a lot of the Waldenmaier info. It listed that it had John and Elizabeth but when I went to it, that was missing ! Don't know why. Here is the site.
http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~saylormowb... I also have pictures of many gravestones in the Medway Christian Cemetery from when we went up. I grew up in NJ and now live in GA. The Garrett side is my Mom's through her Dad. Hope to hear from you.