Message Boards

You are here: Message Boards > Topics > Immigration and Emigration > United States > English Immigrants > Conflicting Immigration Documents -- Which to Believe?
Names or keywords
All Boards   English Immigrants - Family History & Genealogy Message Board

Conflicting Immigration Documents -- Which to Believe?

  Replies: 9

Conflicting Immigration Documents -- Which to Believe?

Tenbinzan  (View posts) Posted: 20 Jul 2010 7:05AM GMT
Classification: Query
Edited: 20 Jul 2010 12:42PM GMT
The 1920 U.S. Census states that my great grandfather came over to the U.S. in 1903, and was naturalized in 1907. This checks out, because the 1907 naturalization laws of the U.S. state that the person seeking citizenship has to have lived continuously in the U.S. for at least five years.

However, I also found a border crossing (from Canada to the U.S.) document . . . I know the man on that document is my great grandfather -- he has the same name, same birth date, lived in the exact same town in England, etc., etc. So I know that it's him on that border crossing document!

The problem is that the document is from May 1907 . . . and supposedly my great grandfather had been living in the U.S. for a continuous five years by then. Hmm.

What does this all mean? Which document is correct?
SubjectAuthorDate Posted
Tenbinzan 20 Jul 2010 7:05AM GMT 
BobNY 20 Jul 2010 9:24PM GMT 
Tenbinzan 23 Jul 2010 9:22PM GMT 
declair59 30 May 2011 3:07PM GMT 
Tenbinzan 23 Jul 2010 9:27PM GMT 
TonyBerry91 6 Feb 2011 1:17PM GMT 
mi2early 6 Feb 2011 2:46PM GMT 
TonyBerry91 6 Feb 2011 3:00PM GMT 
declair59 30 May 2011 3:16PM GMT 
TonyBerry91 30 May 2011 3:22PM GMT 
   

Find a board about a specific topic

Surnames or topics

Page Tools