Search for content in message boards

Distinguishing between British (Great Britain) and German (Europe West)

Replies: 4

Distinguishing between British (Great Britain) and German (Europe West)

Posted: 18 Apr 2015 11:13AM GMT
Classification: Query
According to my AncestryDNA Ethnicity Estimate, 67% of my DNA is from Great Britain and just 10% from Europe West, even though my (very complete) pedigree chart shows that most of my ancestors were from the Rheinland Pfalz region of Germany. I could just dismiss the Ethnicity Estimate as garbage, but I have another theory.

Excepts for the Celts who were there before them, most of the people in Great Britain are descendants of Angles and Saxons, i.e., Germans. What AncestryDNA labels as Great Britain should perhaps be labeled Germany or Europe West. I assume AncestryDNA chose the Great Britain label because many of the people in their initial samples were Mormons, and more Mormons are of English ancestry than of German ancestry.

Genetically, can you really distinguish between the Angles and Saxons who moved to Great Britain and the Germans who remained in Germany? Should there be a broader label that includes both?
SubjectAuthorDate Posted
robertcfryjr2 18 Apr 2015 5:13PM GMT 
bewolff0777 27 Apr 2015 11:10PM GMT 
mattkingtut 1 May 2015 7:10PM GMT 
mattkingtut 1 May 2015 7:08PM GMT 
robertcfryjr2 5 May 2015 12:29AM GMT 
per page

Find a board about a specific topic