Search for content in message boards

Totally new feature in autosomal dna released today...

Replies: 46

Re: Totally new feature in autosomal dna released today...

Posted: 3 Apr 2015 3:19PM GMT
Classification: Query
"I am not bashing trees here. I am saying the tools or processes ancestry provided for people to use with their trees had some issues that frequently reappear. There have been ongoing issues with the relationship calculator providing odd relationships, including relationships to spouses of ancestors rather than the ancestor."

I'm sorry I *will* bash trees. There's only so much an automated tool can do when consolidating data from multiple sources. Genealogy takes work and a real person to manually decide what is accurate to store or not.

Could ancestry offer better tools to make it less work for the user, sure, but let's not pretend that naturally the work shouldn't already lie with the user. If you were using any other software you wouldn't get the full features of the hints and tree merging system you get here at all, so let's not pretend Ancestry is buggering up something easily solved.

As far as relationship calculation, I'll agree with that one, it's fairly easy to see what's going on though, there algorithm simply doesn't value blood relation over the intermarried ones some times, I'm guessing it's weighted to choose the shortest path or the first path etc... Should be an easy fix long ago... but anything else is a lot more complex than people think.
SubjectAuthorDate Posted
smsitton 10 Apr 2015 1:40PM GMT 
kcronin199 11 Apr 2015 12:33PM GMT 
CherylStanfie... 12 Apr 2015 2:19PM GMT 
CherylStanfie... 17 Apr 2015 4:55PM GMT 
mattkingtut 3 Apr 2015 9:19PM GMT 
Marlettes2001 7 Apr 2015 1:43AM GMT 
jbhenning 2 Apr 2015 11:41PM GMT 
mattkingtut 3 Apr 2015 12:18AM GMT 
joyecho 3 Apr 2015 1:05AM GMT 
dvolper 3 Apr 2015 2:14AM GMT 
per page

Find a board about a specific topic