Good Morning Veccalli,

My name is Angie Gant, I am Pearle Garrett's great granddaughter. Her husband is Henry Lewis Rice. And Pearl and Tishie are sisters and not the same woman. You have the correct DOB years for them both. They are both Americas daughters. I'm not sure why anyone would argue about these woman being the same person. There is no question they are sisters. My mom remembers Tishie vividly, and of course Pearl was my moms grandmother. I did notice on ancestry.com that Tishie has Pearl Tishie as her nickname, unfortunately on this website, if one person enters incorrect data, the same record gets passed around for others to use because this is a public site. I hope some of this info helps! Angie