Tammy, there were 2 Esther Renningers.
1) Esther Balthaser Renninger, born 6/15/03 in Upper Bern Township, Berks Co. PA. She married Paul Ernst Becker on 12/25/1920 in Kutztown. They had one child, Irene Mae Becker born 2/8/1923. They divorced in 1930. Esther was living in Shillington, PA in 1984.

2) Esther "Hettie" Renninger, daughter of John and Catherine (Weber) Renninger, was born 10/17/1827 in Ruscombmanor Township, Berks County PA. She married Isaac Bloch on 5/9/1852. They had 8 children.

It seems I've heard the name Sumner Barr before, but don't recall where.