Nice to hear from you. I have in my records that Elizabeth and sarah are sisters, but for the life of me, I cannot find nor recal why I have that? I have Sarah and John (Williams) my GG Grandparents forward to me. Their daughter Emma was my GG Grandmother. I have pictures of both her and Sarah Jane (her sister). Sarah Jane was known to the family as Aunt Jenny. She is buried in the cemetery under Vanderbeek Ware. Much of what I have on Sarah Melville is ambiguous at best Census records have her born in Ireland, England and New York??? So much for those. Do you know the connection to Herman? Is it possible they are siblings? Dates would work. Read Hermans bio on littlebluelight.com, very interesting. I would like to resolve this mystery. I work on it and then put it away for a cuple of years, now that I am old,when I go to pick it up again, I can't remember what the heck I did. Any suggestions on where to go from here? Do you have any pictures of Sarah?