The Hinkleys from Dutchess/Putnam county moved to NE PA near Binghamton area.

My great great grandfather LeRoy Hinkley settled in Lenox PA. Brothers also settled in the area and, as they were farmers, they all had a lot of kids. The spellings of the Hinkleys there have changed with the years. All related but you may want to try Hinckley or Hinklie as both are common there and may be the one you are looking for.