I am Judy Utzler Ermlick.
Our side of the Utzlers has a preponderance of R names and E, and S's!
My father was Ralph (his brother was Elwood)
His father was Samuel Rinaldo (!)-brothers John D. Elmer,Raymond, and sister May
HIs father was Samuel S.
JACOB was Samuel S. father.
He was born in Pa-but near the Ohio line apparently it changed back and forth
My JACOB's brother was William- there are living Utzlers in Ohio decended from William-I have spoken to Herbert.
Ryan, son of Robert who wrote earlier, is a grandson of Raymond (brother of Samuel R above) . Ryan, I remember your grandfather(or gg?) Raymond quite well--a good man.
Could "my Jacob and William" be two of the sons of the Jacob you have been speaking of? "my Jacob" was born 1817.
I know quite a bit about the Samuel, and other sons of Sam S. Utzler-- and "my Jacob" is buried here in Pittsburgh. Pa. in the Keller family plot (daughter?)
I can answer anything about Pittsburgh Utzlers after about 1900.