Thanks so much! Sounds like that fire destroyed any real evidence. :( I wonder if anyone is working on this problem?

I see disagreements on this issue on various websites. From what I read, there was an old genealogy done that said John of Taunton is Samuel Eddy's son, but then current genealogists say that is not true.

Puzzling isn't it! Thanks so much for your reply! If I ever hear of anything I will post again. (I really wish it *could* be resolved, since the Eddy family is an interesting one.) At least I'm not alone in my wondering about it Lol.