I'm looking for Rose Butler's maiden name (and family info) to see if she is related to Rose and Ida McCurdy. I have names and pictures, but no dates or direct link between the McCurdy and Butler families except for the first name of Rose.

Here is the info that I have about ROSE BUTLER:
ROSE BUTLER (b: 8/1861 in Iowa) - her parents are from Illinois
Rose married WILLIAM R. BUTLER (b: 2/1856) in 1875 - his parents are from England
Rose and William had 5 children:
1 - BERTHA BUTLER VOSS (1876-1947) married JOHN CARVER VOSS (1886) - they had 2 children, Marion Voss Fruauff (1901-1970) and John Carver Voss aka "Jack" (b.1912)
**I have more lineage info on Bertha and her family as this is who my husband is descended from.
2 - CHARLES BUTLER (b. 3/1881 NY)
3 - EDNA BUTLER (b. 7/1888)
4 - FLORENCE BUTLER BRINK (b. 12/1889) married EARL BRINK (b. 1885)
5 - MILDRED BUTLER SPENCER

Here are the family members that are related to ROSE MCCURDY:
IDA MCCURDY - Rose's twin sister
GRACE MCCURDY MANTUR(sp?) - relative
DEB MCCURDY - aunt
DOUGLAS MCCURDY - relative

I believe that ROSE MCCURDY is ROSE BUTLER, but I do not have any information other than names and pictures of the McCurdy family members listed above.

Can anyone help? I've attached pictures of all the McCurdy family members and the only picture of Rose Butler as an adult.
Megan
meganmcnerney@comcast.net