Very Old Post but I think your James died 17 Sep 1902 in Goldtown, Jackson, West Virginia..Showing his father's name as H Barnhart...I believe James is a brother to George Washington Barnhart also born in Pennsylvania...His death record shows G Barnhart as Father...Not been able to follow them and do not really have proof that they are brothers...If you have made any progress, please share with me...Thanx!