Where was your Caldwell born and what years do you have? I have a James Caldwell born in Wyoming County, NY June 12 1815. I have yet to find his father's name but state census tells me that his father was born in NH and his mother was born in Mass.
I was just starting a frantic search because a 130 yr old historic building in the town of Castile in Wyoming County burned this morning and they may have LOST a LOT of HISTORIC RECORDS!!! It was the Town Office buildings and nothing was kept in Fire proof safes!!! I never checked that town for information on Caldwell!!!