Like you, I am at a loss. I am trying to figure out if this is the John McReynolds who had a son Peter Wesley McReynolds. I am not sure if this is the right John. There seem to be several...

Some of the facts add up, but I need to keep digging. Please share if you discover anything.

I've seen Ahollabamy's name spelled Alabama (Bamey - nickname) Waggoner on some documents. I will wade back in and see if I can find that.