I don't know the time period of your ancestor, but Rev. R. J. Perkins was a pastor of the Custer Methodist Church in 1946. In 1954, he could have been working for the Antioch church. In 1972, it is possible he was in Louisville at High Plains Methodist Church. I saw no mention of a church for McDaniels. I also found a McDaniel cemetery in Hancock county. All cemetery lists are available online, I am sure you know. Like you, I saw no McCarty. I don't know if you tried but, but contact information for Antioch church in Leitchfield was a P.O. Box address in McDaniels and I guess I would start with them cause the pastor might live in the area.