I am not sure where the James that keeps getting added to Arthur's name comes from. He is always referred to as Arthur in the records and it states on a census record that he was born in Ireland. Has anyone found any record of what happened to his son Michael, who was deaf and dumb and lived with Arthur until Arthur's death? I did find Martha Fitzgerald Mcgaughey living in a boarding house in Frankfort with one of her daughters after Arthur died. The second family seems to have moved towards Lexington and allied with the members of the family from Amos, the line that eventually gives us Shug... Kentucky derby winning horse trainer.