Here is how I have it and I have the information from other family trees not indepentant research. It is little off-line for me too.

Frances McCutcheon-No parents listed.

Samuel Sanford "Sr." McCutcheon parents are:
Lt. William McCutcheon and Eleanor Fulton.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I am of the James H. McCutcheon Line thru Fulton McCutcheon. Actual spelling is "McCutchen." until Fulton's son, John F. McCutcheon and my great-grandfather, changed the spelling to McCutcheon, some time before 1870 and after 1860.