Nowhere in the county in 1905, 1908, 1909 can I find anyone that seems like a possibility. Nowhere in the state in the 1910 census. BUT:

1910 Census, Ohio, Erie Co., Sandusky first ward
(portland twp.), p. 5B line 71:

Stellhorn, Theodore .... minister, Zion Lutheran Church

probably came in from out of town to do the honors.