Great to hear from you! Margaret 'Peggy' (Drew) McEvoy was indeed the sister of Judith (Drew) Turtle. I think Judith was also the godmother of my great-great-great-great-grandmother, Bridget Agnes (McEvoy) Stanley.

I don't have a current subscription to Ancestry, so I can't contact you through the site, but I think you're able to send me a message. If you could do so and include your email address, I'd be more than happy to chat about the connections.