Mike,
Very interesting, but wonder at it being part of our family as Samuel Sheetz died about 1873 (your info) and Betsy is listed on the 1880 U S Census in Middleway, Jefferson Co, WV On the 1880 U S census, the name is recorded as Eliza H Randal with Mary Randal (Wooddy), w, f, 5 bn WV and Charles E Randal,(Wooddy) w, m, 10, bn WV, children of Robert and Delia Woody, are also listed in the household..
I figured Elizabeth(Eliza/Betsy)Kelly Reynolds Sheets died between 1884 and 1891 based on when my ancestors left Jefferson Co, WV for Fayette Co, PA.