I just got new ethnicity results from 23 and Me. The various sources are beginning to come together. Here is a comparison:

My family origins (4 generations)

Ireland: 44%
Great Britain (England and Wales): 8%
West European: 38%, of which: German: 25%, Flemish/Dutch: 13%
Scandinavian (Norman): 6%

New 23 and Me results (speculative mode; subregional):

British/Irish: 64.5%
French/German: 9,4%
Scandinavian: 3.8%
Non Specific Northern Europe: 19.5%
Non Specific Southern Europe: 0.8%
Non Specific Europe: 2%

Ancestry.com:

Ireland: 46%
Great Britain: 5%
Europe West: 43%
Finnish/Northern Russia: 2%
Scandinavia: <1%
Iberian: <1%
Italy/Greece: 1%
European Jewish <1%
Europe East: <1%

Gedmatch Eurogenes Eutest (Oracle X)

Ireland: 9%
England: 52%
Scotland: 8%
German: 1%
Netherlands: 15%
Norwegian: 3%
Other: 14%

Family Tree DNA Population Finder and Dr. McDonald have me as 100% Orcadian and British Isles respectively, but hopefully Population Finder will be updated soon.

Jim