I wondered if you would be willing to give me the benefit of your experience again. I now have the marriage certificate for Joseph and Elizabeth, married at Chester st Mary's, 30 May 1866. Crucially, Elizabeth's father is listed as Robert
Roberts, which ties in with what we already know from family documents. Joseph is listed as a carter. The Joseph I have been looking for who I had followed back s far as the 1871 census was also a carter. Joseph's father according to the marriage cert is James. So I looked for James and found a family, James (b Chester abt 1800) and wife
Hannah (b
Hawarden abt 1795) and children, including Joseph and have been able to trace them forward through to 1881 when
Hannah appears to have died (BMD index) aged 86, just after the census. Again, a key link is the census address. The Joseph I had already found back to 1871 and whom I have high degree of confidence is my GG grandfather, lived at
Lane End in the
Flintshire Parish of Pentrobin (the Buckley-Hawarden area). The 1841 census shows James and family also living at
Lane End and this address is preserved in the family right up to 1881, when
Hannah is still there. So all the clues point to this being the family I have been looking for. But there are two aspects troubling me a little. First there is the fact that the marriage cert lists Joseph and Elizabeth living in Saltney, not
Buckley (close, but not the same place) and indeed, why did they get married in Chester anyway if they were living in
Flintshire (by the way, James disappears from the census in after 1851 and so I assume was not at the wedding even though he is named on the cert). Second, there is a problem, as I said before abotu Joseph's year of birth. All the census records suggest that he was born around 1836-38. But according to the marriage cert this Joseph was 26 in 1866. In this case there is also a problem with Elizabeth's birth date. Our family records say she was born on 2 January 1846, but according to the marriage cert, she claimed then to have been born in 1843. Why would they both get married in Chester, pretending to be about three years younger than other documents say they were? Or is it just that these are the wrong people, in which case what am I to make of all the things about them above that do tie up? Is there anything obvious that I should be doing next to test out the facts I have so far collated?
Sorry to trouble you with this, but you seem to have a great deal of experience and may have some ideas which could help me.