Fannie Alice Salkill McMonigle died on July 15, 1903. She was married to Daniel E McMonigle died 1933. We were told they died at the same time.....murdered and all they children were farmed out to relatives. They have been listed as living in Payneville, KY and New Amsterdam, Harrison County, IN..

So I am not sure why Grandmother said both her parents were murdered......but it was not true. Fannie may have been.....but I can not find any info online to solve this mystery. My grandmother didn't see her sibling again for 50 yrs when reunited.

If you have information of what might have happen that caused Fannies Death, it would be appreciated.

Fannie Alice was a half sister to my Hubby's grandmother... Viola Ann Salkill Jupin. We have just been asked about the murder of 'Alice' but so far have fond nothing.... still looking. All the family that could help us is probably long gone,

Thank you. That is more that I have found. Do you know any info about Fannie Alice, Her parents, where they lived.

Any info would we helpful.

Here is what we have bee able to learn so far and it's not absolutely confirmed..... it is a work in progress. The descendat file is at the bottom and just barely begun. Hope this helps. I'll share whatever else we are able to find... and hope you will do the same.

Ancestors of Fanny A. Salkill

Generation No. 1

1. Fanny A. Salkill, born 12 Apr 1869 in Harrison Co., IN; died 15 Jun 1903 in Meade Co. , KY and is buried in Mt Zion Cemetery, Harrison Co., IN. She was the daughter of 2. John Wesley Salkill and 3. Margaret Hoffman. She married (1) Daniel E. Mcmonigle 30 Dec 1888 in Harrison Co., IN. He was born 30 Oct 1868 in Harrison Co., IN, and died 12 Feb 1933 in Harrison Co., IN and is buried in Mt Zion Cemetery, Harrison Co., IN.

Generation No. 2

2. John Wesley Salkill, born Jun 1846 in Scott Co., IN; died 15 Dec 1896 in Harrison Co., IN and is buried in Mt Zion Cemetery, Harrison Co., IN. He was the son of 4. David Salkill and 5. Mary 'Polly'Kimberlin. He married 3. Margaret Hoffman 22 Jul 1868 in Harrison Co., IN.
3. Margaret Hoffman

Notes for John Wesley Salkill:
Name: John W Saltkill
Residence: Charlestown, Indiana
Enlistment Date: 26 Jul 1862
Rank at enlistment: Private
State Served: Indiana
Survived the War?: Yes
Service Record: Enlisted in Co. D, Indiana 4th Cavalry Regiment on 26 Jul 1862.
Source: Report of the Adjutant General of the State of Indiana

Child of John Salkill and Margaret Hoffman is:
1 i. Fanny A. Salkill, born 12 Apr 1869 in Harrison Co., IN; died 15 Jun 1903 in Meade Co. , KY and is buried in Mt Zion Cemetery, Harrison Co., IN; married Daniel E. Mcmonigle 30 Dec 1888 in Harrison Co., IN.


Generation No. 3

4. David Salkill, born ca 1814 in Maryland; died 1891. He was the son of 8. John Salkill and 9. Lucy Smith. He married 5. Mary 'Polly'Kimberlin.
5. Mary 'Polly'Kimberlin, born 09 Jul 1821 in Scott Co., IN; died 1857 in Scott Co., IN.

Children of David Salkill and Mary 'Polly'Kimberlin are:
2 i. John Wesley Salkill, born Jun 1846 in Scott Co., IN; died 15 Dec 1896 in Harrison Co., IN and is buried in Mt Zion Cemetery, Harrison Co., IN; married (1) Margaret Hoffman 22 Jul 1868 in Harrison Co., IN; married (2) Frances Ann 'Fannie' Bruce 22 Jan 1871 in Harrison Co., IN.
ii. Henry C. Salkill, born ca 1841 in Scott Co., IN; died 1875.
iii. James Thomas Salkill, born ca 1844 in Scott Co., IN; died 1867.
iv. Abraham Alonzo Salkill, born ca 1847 in Scott Co., IN; died 1908.
v. Benjamin Salkill, born ca 1849 in Scott Co., IN.
vi. Samuel Salkill, born ca 1851 in Scott Co., IN; died 1917.
vii. Jacob Salkill, born ca 1852 in Scott Co., IN; died 1900.

Generation No. 4

8. John Salkill He was the son of 16. William Salkill and 17. Sarah Hampton. He married 9. Lucy Smith.
9. Lucy Smith

Child of John Salkill and Lucy Smith is:
4 i. David Salkill, born ca 1814 in Maryland; died 1891; married (1) Mary 'Polly'Kimberlin..


Generation No. 5

16. William Salkill He married 17. Sarah Hampton.
17. Sarah Hampton

Child of William Salkill and Sarah Hampton is:
8 i. John Salkill, married Lucy Smith.

-------------------------------------------
Descendants of Fanny A. Salkill


Generation No. 1

1. FANNY A.5 SALKILL (JOHN WESLEY4, DAVID3, JOHN2, WILLIAM1) was born 12 Apr 1869 in Harrison Co., IN, and died 15 Jun 1903 in Meade Co. , KY and is buried in Mt Zion Cemetery, Harrison Co., IN. She married DANIEL E. MCMONIGLE 30 Dec 1888 in Harrison Co., IN. He was born 30 Oct 1868 in Harrison Co., IN, and died 12 Feb 1933 in Harrison Co., IN and is buried in Mt Zion Cemetery, Harrison Co., IN.

Children of FANNY SALKILL and DANIEL MCMONIGLE are:
i. ELMER PERRY6 MCMONIGLE.
ii. OLLIE R. MCMONIGLE.
iii. NANCY BELLE MCMONIGLE.
iv. SAMUEL MAYFIELD MCMONIGLE.

Records indicate there is one more child, we do not have, yet.

I noticed the discussion on Daniel E. McMonigle and Fannie Alice Salkill. Daniel was a brother of my grandfather, Henry Fairly McMonigle. The Daniel/Fannie relationship has always been somewhat of a mystery in my research.
My research indicates she was born in Meade County, Kentucky rather than Harrison County but my sources were not a primary sources and I made an assumption. One source showed she was born at "Sirocco, Kentucky." This happends to be where Daniel's parents were living at the time.
I show she married Daniel E. McMonigle on "December 20, 1888" in Harrison County, Indiana. In addition the four children you reported, they had a son John D. McMonigle, born 12 Jul 1902 and died 7 Sep 1922. He was killed in a tree cutting accident. I have his obituary.
It is ironic that Fannie is rumored to have been "murdered." There is also a rumor in my McMonigle family line that my grandfather, Henry, killed Daniel E. McMonigle even though it was ruled a suicide.
I show Fannie's mother as "Margaret Huffman" but researchers have disagreed on this one.

David L. McMonigle
Edgewater, Florida
dmcmonigle@cfl.rr.com

Hello David,
I found John D. after I posted my findings. It was an interesting, albeit sad, search with no answers to the question of how Fannie died. All of the dates and available records leave little doubt Fannie is Margaret Huffman's daughter. I truly wish the rest of the story was as easy to see. Ron's Salkill line has tested us many times.... and continues to do so.

Name: Daniel E McMonigle
Spouse Name: Fannie A Salkil
Marriage Date: Dec 20 1888
Marriage County: Harrison