Thank you Kathy Roberts,
My ancestor who the family claims was Creek Indian is my great great grandmother Mary Louise (Molly) Hardy. Here is her profile: "When Mary Louise (Molly) Hardy was born on April 10, 1859, in Alabama, her father, Mitchell, was 52, and her mother, Louisa, was 31. She married Jonathan Willis on December 25, 1875, in Escambia, Florida. They had 11 children in 19 years. She died on January 21, 1937, in Escambia, Florida, at the age of 77." Escambia County Alabama is where a large tribe of Creek Indians live, then and still today. They are called the Poarch Band of Creek Indians.
"Molly's" parents are Mitchell G. Hardy and Louisa Ann Dukes, her paternal grandparents are Jesse Hardy and Celia Golding or Golden, her maternal grandparents are Thomas Bush Dukes and Ann Montgomery.
Thanks for any help you can give me to resolve this mystery.