I am totally confused and am wondering if anyone can help me figure out who is the correct JOHN SHAW married to ALICE PHILLIPS. Here is what I have:

#1 John Shaw b. 1600 London, England d. 10-24-1694 Middleborro, MA
m. Alice Phillips b. 1604 Plymouth, MA d. 3-6-1653
CH: James 1632 m. Mary Mitchell; John Jr. 1625 m. ? ; Jonathan 3-2-1628/9
m. Phebe Watson

#2 John Shaw b. 1630 Halifax Parrish, Yorkshire, England D. 9-16-1704 Weymouth, MA
m. Alice Phillips b. 1636 Wendover, England d. 9-1-1672
CH: Elizabeth 1656; Abraham 1657; Mary 1659; Nicholas 1661; Joseph 1664; Alice 1666; Hannah 1668; Benjamin 1670; Ebenezer 1674; Abigail 1672 m. to Richard Davenport

My last question is does Abigail belong to John Shaw #2?

Your help would greatly be appreciated. Thank you.