Dear Jim,
You may have this information already, but I posted this quite awhile ago. If you will go to this post, you will see a letter written to my father which I quoted and which confirms information on one of your Tuttles arriving on the Planter.
Tuttle family names and dates from letter dated 1960 Anne Wiggins Smith... 0 11 May 2011

Farther down on the page is another post which contains a list of the Tuttle names in my family which were copied by my aunt Margaret Wiggins Uzzle from a family bible. I'm hoping for to find a connection for Robert Tuttle.

Thanks,
Anne Wiggins Smith