Codi,
Im not sure if we have a Toohey (or any of the other 28 varieties of the spelling) but I had Tooheys living in Philadelphia from about 1866 through about 1910. My GGGF Dennis Toohey b. abt 1840, IRE with spouse Ann (working on surname) immigrated to Philadelphia about 1866 with children: Mary, Margaret, John - then had children in PA - Bridget, Annie (my GGM) and William. Dennis was a stevedore and lived near the docks on the deleware river. On 1870 census he's listed as "Tuey" and in 1880 as "Tooley". Cannot find him on 1900. In 1910 he is listed as a patient in the Phil. Gen. Hosp. though the listing on ancestorydotcom says "Tookey". It says he is 73 from Ireland (not Italy) and immigtd. in 1866. Now, I have found out all about my GGM Annie but absolutely NOTHING about any of the others - my philadelphia tooheys really dropped through the cracks of history. I just thought since we both have tooheys living in Philly that we should share info. Let me know what you think. I hope you get this, it was rather an old posting. thanks!
brian