You probably have found what you are looking for by now, but I am slowly putting together info about the Ohio Mayberry families. My family includes Wells Mayberry, b. 1827, Ohio.
If I have matched things up correctly - only by online info - it appears that James wife (Mrs. Rachel Teegarden), married 1862, Allen County, is the widow of Henry Teegarden. If so, her name when she married Henry was Rachel Decker. Henry and Rachel Decker married 1834. In 1880 census, Rachel Mayberry has daughter, Annis Mayberry, b. 1862, and son, Daniel Teegarden, b. 1856. If I have done the math right, James Mayberry must have died 1861-2?
If anyone has old photos or copies of family Bibles pertaining to these families, I would love to see them. Any info appreciated.