You have really confounded me with Abby Squibb (Abigail May). I thought I knew them all in this branch since it is mine. But I did back track and find her with Eliza Ann Mains Squibb, wife of Abraham Greenawalt Squibb in the 1910 census and in the 1900 Census, she is listed with Ella Nora Squibb visiting the Milward family of Mount Pleasant, Westmoreland Co., PA. So I will need to see if I can find who she belongs to. Abraham Greenawalt Squibb and his wife Eliza Ann Mains had 9 children, Caleb Francis, Martha Jane, Jesse Mains, Finley Watson, Caleb F., Mary Rebecca, Ella Nora, Ida Mae and Abram Edwin. Abigail May must belong to one of those as Abraham Greenawalt Squibb's siblings were all sisters. His father was one of two sons and the other brother went out to Iowa. Anyway, please do correspond with me at
squibb_chesley@verizon.net, as I am directly related to this branch of the family