I recently came across a letter written in 1897 from Flora Sigafoose Windell to her cousin George Henry SIGAFOOSE, Jr.. She was living in Winchester, Frederick Co., VA, and had been for some time. GH Jr. was living in Columbus Grove, Putnam Co., OH. In this letter, she mentioned many relatives, including her famliy. Husband George Windell, son Luther, daughter Birchie and daughter Sue. She also noted a visit to Toledo, OH in 1891 where she met Aunt Maria and Aunt Rosanna and their children. Rosanna's were George and William. Flora had a brother Robbert (2 'b's), an uncle John Sigafoose, and an uncle George Henry Sigafoose, beside her aunts.
This letter adds a whole generation to this branch of the Sigafoose's. Discovery of the Toledo branch is also new to me. Does this click with anyone you are researching?