My DNA testing has connected with the DNA of a descendent of the Pendleton Co. KY Shivley's. The common ancestor appears to be John Shivley of Pendleton Co., KY (b. 21 Nov 1753 ). His son Daniel Shiveley (b. about 1782) moved to Adams Co. OH in early 1800's. His wife Mary was born about 1790 in KY, and his first son James was born in Adams Co., OH in 1811.
Detailed information available at:
http://www.shivs.com/shively/genealogy/