Perhaps this will help:
John L Shaar m. Anna R Hollinger (b 26 Nov 1857) in Rothsville, Lancaster County, PA. He was a cigar manufacturer. Their children were Elmer M. (b. 16 Aug 1883 Akron, PA), Benjamin H (b 24 Jan 1891 Rothsville, d. Oct 1974 Ephrata, Lancaster Co, PA), and Mabel B. (b 8 Oct 1893, Rothsville). Source: "The Zartman Family" by Rev Rufus Calvin Zartman, Pastor of Heidelburg Reformed Church, Philadelphia PA, publised 1909.

I also have more info on Elmer, and on ancestry of Anna, if it will help.