Jackie:
None of the names you gave me "ring any bells", however,doesn't mean I won't contact you. One thing for sure you aren't in my direct line. On other RENNINGER lines. I have made little effort.
I decend from Frederick Renninger who arrived in the Port of Philadelphia in 1754. He was my sixth great grandfather.
To see if I can be of any assistance, please give me your earliest ancestor, location and reference dates. I'll see if I can find any connection. Have records acquired over the last 35 years.
Don Renninger
Jacksonville, FL