Mlkreider1:
We are definitely related since my Pumarejo surname comes from barrio Arenales of Aguadilla, Puerto Rico. During that time he was born barrio Arenales had less than 900 people; it was so small that on the 1899 United States Census that it combined both barrio Arenales & Aguacate, which totaled 900 people.
Send me a message if you want to know more.
Your Cousin,
Juan