Our family history book has a Catherine Elizabeth Pelster born November 10, 1838, in Germany. Many things are so close that I wonder if it is the same woman. She was the daughter of Garrot H. Pelster I and Elizabeth Oldenburger. They lived in Fort Loramie, Shelby County, Ohio, after they left Germany (about 1864). Her husbands: Franciscum Joseph
Holgrevum, Bernard Henric Baumhove, Joseph Tabeling...at least that is what is listed. There is one child listed: Catherine E. Baumhove.
The Anna could have been a confirmation name that she chose as a youngster that she chose to use. I have found through several years of research the names tended to be much more "flexible" in the past than they are today.
I can tell you a little more about her ancestry and siblings if you think this is the same woman.
K