We believe my husband and son are descended through Caleb Nye and Hannah Bodfish as well. This is the lineage as far as we understand it:

1. Caleb Nye and Hannah Bodfish
2. Benjamin Nye and Susann (Susannah) Phinney
3. Sylvanus Nye and Mary Banks
4. Zeba(h) Nye and Abigail Baker
5. James Ling and Caroline Nye
6. John V. Ling and Mattie Woodruff
7. Erma B. Ling and Paul H. Walton

Erma and Paul Walton's daughter, Ruth, was my husband's grandmother.

So far I haven't found the time or resources to verify this lineage (I have one contact who may be able to help me out in the near future but can't do it at this time either). In any case, I wanted to join in this conversation... it's reassuring to me to see other folks investigating the same families!