Eli Nutick and Margaret(te) Weiss were born in Germany. They were in Ohio by the time their first child, Valentine Nutick was born. Other children: Alice Elizabeth b. 1871 in Madisonville (Cincinnati), Hamilton Co., OH, Charles, Harry, Carrie, And Emma. The name wasn't originally Nutick, but possibly Utig, Ludwig or ? I have been unable to find them in the Ohio census records until 1900 even though they were there in 1870 and 1880. I believe that their name was "mis" recorded by census takers and I just haven't located them yet. Alice Elizabeth Nutick m. George P. Armstrong and moved first to Kansas and then later to Washington State. The Armstrong family helped settle Anderson Twp., in Hamilton County, Ohio and there is much information available about them. Valentine never married and is buried with his mother Margaret Nutick at a cemetery in Madisonville.