Thanks Monica. Now I have the right notes ... from the 1910 census in Idaho: Joseph M. keatinge aged 53, married for second time, born in Ohio (i was wrong before). His wife Carrie age 33, married for first time, married for 11 years, bornin Rhode Island. Children were Mary J., aged 25; Helen M., 22; Agnes G., 19; Joseph C., 17; Paul F., 9; Caroline L. 7; William B., 5; A. Elizabeth, 4. Good luck.