My family as well has tried to track down all of the Internicola's. I'll tell you what I know. I was raised on Long Island, NY with most of my direct Internicola relatives. Some of my other relatives have settled in New Jersey, Staten Island and Toronto, Canada. My Granfather is Joe Internicola who was born in the Lower East side on Manhattan in the 1920's. He has two brothers and a sister, Sammy, Jimmy, and Vivian. My granfather's parents were Paul & Marie Internicola who originally came over from
Castelllimare, Italy in the early 1900's.
There was another Internicola family on Long Island when I was growing up but we never were able to figure out how we would have been related. There also Internicola's in Boston.
If anyone has questions or comment shoot me an email.
Ciao