Bruce: This query deserves more discussion than I can make here. I've worked on the Icenogle name for 23 years. Sally (a nickname?) has been a puzzle to me, but I've got a couple of ideas. I believe that Charlotte was the daughter of Abraham Icenogle, but no proof. However, the ties to Delaware Co. IN, would seem to relate to the descendants of Thomas Eisennagel. Please contact me at the email address above. Do you know from what part of Kentucky James Hensley came? Best. Roger