I believe the Tom Icards are the same. My information is "Thomas A. Icard, born 1861 Harrison County, (Va)WV, spouses were Mahala Murry and Ida A. Adams. His siblings were: Homer Nicholas Icard "Nick" (my great grandfather on my mother's side) born 28 Nov 1861 Harrison County, died 10 Feb 1923, married Mary Lee Vandale, 22 April 1881. Martha F. Icard born 1863 Taylor County, Va (WV), my grandmother was their daugher, Laura D. Icard Cain. - Martha F. Icard, born 1863 Taylor County, PA (now WV), married 28 Oct 1880 tp William G. Vandergrift - Marietta Icard born 1865 PA, married unknown Forshey - Emma E. Icard born about 1866 in Barbour County, WV, married 12 March 1882 in Roane County to J.J.A. Morrison, and Diadema Icard, born 1870 in Harrison County, married 28 Oct 1886 in Roane County to Hiram M. Chancy. The parents of these children were ISAIAH ICARD married Jullia Ann Watts. Isaiah died 23 Feb 190a and is buried in Roach Cemetary, Roane County. Isaiah was widowed by age 42, he remarried to Elizabeth Marcelia and had 6 more children, r of whom wre living as of the 1900 Roane County Census. I found a copy of his obituary in my grandmother's bible and if you are interested, I will type it for you and send it.