Hi Kristen,
Some additional info regarding 'my' Frank Herally. He was born 17 FEB 1871 in near Tonet, WI. He died on 15 APR 1947 in Lena at the home of his niece, Mrs. Joseph Early. His parents were Michael Heraly and Mary Anna Bonjean. After his mother died in 1885, his grandfather, Felix Constant Bonjean was his guardian. I believe that he was on his own when in his teens. He went out west for a while - apparently as a logger, but returned to Wisconsin. He remained in contact with his younger sister Suzanne (Annie) and Ida.
If this seems like a possible match, I would love to see a scan of the photo and see if either of his living nieces are able to recognize the photo.