I started my search for my grandfather in 1997. To date I have found only conflicting information. David married? Lilly Ivey Stewart from Manitoba, Canada. Lilly died in Idaho in 1923. They had a daughter in Minnesota in 1917, certificate says he was born in Illinois,1881. Son born in Idaho, cert. says he was born in New York, 1867. Son born in Idaho, cert. says he was born in New York, 1865. David died in Sacramento, CA in 1943, married to an Eliza, this cert, says he was born in Canada, cert, says he was born June 2, 1879.
David had a sister, Matilda married to Albert Perrin in Ottatwa Canada 1940 and 1942. 1920 census says he was born in Canada 1888.