out of curoisity, I found a tree with a barbara duncan in it whom is married to a william goodman b. 1853, but the owner has her first name listed as catherine barbara duncan b. 1853 d. 1882; they were married in 1879 children listed as susan augusta (1856 - 1882 ) and a perry t (1880-1943)(assuming t stands for thomas)

any relation ??? or way off base