Hi,
I am also at a brick wall with this couple. Their daughters Drucilla and Almira Jane married men with the last name of Dickout and lived in Ontario. My husband is related to Charles Arthur Ervin who lived a great part of his life in Ontario but is buried in Eagle River WI.
Tabitha Jane Stuart uses the name Elmira in the wedding records for her daughters. I was going to try searching more with that name to see what might come up. It appears the members of this family changed their names over the course of their lives. At one point George was a baptist preacher so looking into the history of the church where he served is another avenue I intend to pursue.
Thanks, Mary G for the info you have provided.