I have begun my search into the Elyea name. I was born in Marshall, MI an Elyea. So far I have traced it to James and Sallie Clearwater(1785) in New York. I believe he is the son of Jacob (1771), but that's where it gets confusing. If anyone is looking at this surname, I would love any information! My great grandfather was Charles F. Elyea Sr., his father was Robert Peter Elyea, his father Peter Elyea. Peter's father was the James mentioned first. Thanks for any help. Sonya