I have read many messages on the RootsWeb Elkin family list, but still can't figure out whether Rev. Robert Elkin's father was Nathaniel Elkin or John Elkin. Is there any consensus among Elkin family researchers as to which is correct? Also, I note that some Elkin reseachers assign a second wife (Elizabeth Harvey) to Rev. Robert Elkin. Is there any consensus there? Thanks. Bill Simpson, Richmond, VA