I was following the lineage you described and either your message is missing a few generations or I have something very wrong. I have listed that the parents of James C. Edgell are William
Edgell and Sarah
Dunn. William Edgell's parents were James
Edgell and Mary Ice. It is Mary Ice who comes from William "Indian Billy" Ice and Margaret
Higginbotham. As such the beginning of your lineage would look like this:
Frederick Ice (1680-1796) m. Mary
Galloway (1680-1745)
William "Indian Billy" Ice (1730-1826) m. Margaret
Higginbotham (1749-1804)
Mary Ice (1775-?) m. James
Edgell (1775-1805)
William
Edgell(? - 1844) m. Sarah
Dunn (1804-1877)
James C. Edgell (1820-1895) m. Mary Jane
Cain (1828-1898)
Charles Wesley
Edgell (...)
** Frederick Ice (1680-1796) was also married to Eleanor
Levingston in 1752
** William "Indian Billy" Ice (1730-1826) was also married to Mary Scott
McMillan as well as Elizabeth
Shreve (1778-?)
** Mary Ice (1775-?) was also married to
Abraham Shreve** Sarah
Dunn (1804-1877) was also married to John
Keller (1793-?)
I am still working through confirming all of this information, but for now this is what I have listed.