My goodness cousin Melissa, this is a tremendous amount of sleuthing done, wading through all the inconsistencies in record keeping. I think your reasoning is very sound in reaching all of these conclusions. I am going to look over your message carefully. My parents are coming here for the weekend, but after they leave, I will enter it all in my gedcom and do a few checks myself to see if I might find anything with all my various subscriptions. Then I have a long haul in looking through all my Huff stuff and sending you what I find in it that can help you. I will try to find the photocopy of the photo as well of M.V.B. Huff's second family to send to you.